Tag: Eu Ai Act

  • The Editorial Test: How an August 2 Deadline, a 190-Signature Code, and a Spell-Check Carve-Out Are Deciding Who Has to Say “It Was AI”

    The Editorial Test: How an August 2 Deadline, a 190-Signature Code, and a Spell-Check Carve-Out Are Deciding Who Has to Say “It Was AI”

    On August 2, 2026, the EU AI Act’s transparency obligations became the first binding content-labeling regime to take effect in a major Western market. The rules do not ban AI in news. They put a price on publishing machine-written text that nobody reviewed.


    What Changed on August 2

    The EU AI Act entered into force on August 1, 2024, and applies in stages. The stage that matters for media arrived on August 2, 2026, when Article 50 — the Act’s transparency article — took effect. From that date, four obligations bind the parties involved in producing and publishing synthetic content:[1]

    • Chatbots and AI agents must announce themselves (Article 50(1)). Providers of systems that interact directly with people must tell users they are dealing with AI, unless it is obvious to a reasonably well-informed user. The guidelines are explicit that disclosure buried in terms and conditions, readable only by machines, or stated generically (“this system uses LLMs”) is not sufficient — and AI agents must disclose both their artificial nature and the person on whose behalf they are acting.[2]
    • Providers must mark machine-generated outputs machine-readably (Article 50(2)). The company that builds a generative system must ensure its outputs carry marks a computer can detect as artificially generated — the invisible layer underneath the visible label.
    • Emotion recognition and biometric categorisation must be disclosed (Article 50(3)), at the latest on first exposure to the people being scanned.[1]
    • Deepfakes and AI-generated public-interest text must be labelled (Article 50(4)). Whoever publishes image, audio, or video content that “resemble[s] existing persons, objects, places, entities, or events” — or text published to inform the public on matters of public interest — must disclose its artificial origin, subject to one exception.[1]

    Enforcement sits with national market surveillance authorities, the European Commission’s AI Office, and, where EU institutions are the culprits, the European Data Protection Supervisor. Companies face fines of up to 15 million euros or 3% of global annual turnover, whichever is higher; EU institutions face up to 750,000 euros, with proportionality rules tempering the numbers for small and medium-sized enterprises.[1]

    The design logic is worth pausing on, because it explains why this landed in the media domain and not, say, the consumer-safety domain. The Commission’s own framing is that AI has made it “increasingly difficult to distinguish AI-generated and manipulated content from human-created and authentic content,” creating “new risks of misinformation and manipulation at scale.”[1] In other words, the reader-side test — can a person tell? — has failed. So Article 50 moves the detection burden upstream from the audience, who cannot tell, to the publishers and providers, who can. The law does not require anyone to stop using AI. It requires the people who know what the machine did to say so.

    Two scoping decisions define the regime’s practical reach. First, the deepfake test is objective: intent to deceive is not required, and photorealism is not decisive — the content need only depict a subject that is “plausibly real,” which catches AI-generated actors and digital replicas while leaving wholly fantastical content outside.[2] Second, the public-interest trigger for text is construed broadly, covering “politics and democratic process, public services, justice, fundamental rights, public security, health, environment, consumer safety, and economic, financial, scientific and cultural matters relevant to public debate” — but not AI-generated fiction, product descriptions, or a chatbot reply seen only by the person who asked.[2] A few technical deadlines were also deferred under the Digital Omnibus revisions: systems already on the market have until December 2, 2026 to meet the marking obligation, and watermark-detection interoperability is required by February 2, 2027. Content published before August 2, 2026 does not need to be labelled retroactively.[2]


    The Spell-Check Line: How the Editorial Exception Works

    Article 50(4) is the provision that reaches newsrooms, and its entire regulatory weight sits on one exception. AI-generated public-interest text must be disclosed unless “the AI-generated text has undergone a process of human review or editorial control by a natural or legal person with responsibility.”[2] That carve-out is where the Commission drew the line between journalism and automation — and the finalised guidelines, published July 20, 2026, make the bar deliberately high:

    • Competence is required. The reviewing person must have the relevant competence to judge the substance; the review must be a real examination, not a glance.[2]
    • Spell-checking does not count. The guidelines state plainly that “spell-checking or cursory sign-off” is not sufficient to trigger the exception.[2]
    • The exception can be lost after the fact. Any substantive AI edit applied after the human review removes the exception — the review has to be the last meaningful pass.[2]
    • Assertions are not enough. Under the Code of Practice, claiming the editorial exception “requires documented workflows, not solely assertions that such review took place.”[2]

    The Media and Journalism Research Center, which is running a multi-country study of how European news organisations are implementing the rule, captures what this design actually does:

    “It does not ban newsrooms from using AI, and it does not require a label on everything AI touches. It ties the duty to disclose to how editorial oversight and responsibility are organised. That makes it a question about how journalism is run, not about technology.”[3]

    That is the core logic of the whole regime. The EU did not write a technology rule that asks “was AI used?” — a question with a binary, often meaningless answer, since nearly every modern newsroom uses AI somewhere in its pipeline. It wrote an accountability rule that asks “who stood behind what was published?” A newsroom with a real editor is regulated by its own editor. A pipeline that auto-publishes machine text is regulated by the label it must now carry. Labrador, a CMS vendor that built Article 50 compliance tooling for newsrooms, puts the dividing line in one sentence: “publishers who keep a human in the loop should feel very little of Article 50. Publishers who auto-publish AI text carry all of it.”[4]

    There is a catch that cuts both ways, and CMS vendors are already building for it: under a regime where the exception requires documented workflows, “you may someday need to prove the human review happened, not just that it could have.”[4] The practical consequence is that the edit log becomes a compliance artifact — the same workflow feature that was once an internal newsroom nicety is now the evidentiary basis for the entire exemption.


    The 190-Signature Code: Regulating by Codebook Instead of Courtroom

    Article 50 tells publishers what to do; the Code of Practice on Transparency of AI-generated Content tells them how, and it is the most quietly consequential document in this story. Drafted by independent experts, finalised in June 2026, and assessed as adequate by both the Commission and the AI Board, the Code offers signatories “a streamlined, predictable and legally certain pathway to guarantee and demonstrate compliance, regardless of the place where the organisations operate or the competent supervisory authority.”[5] By end of July 2026, about 190 organisations had signed; as of the September 17, 2026 update, the Code counts 95 signatories to its provider section and 192 to its deployer section, with about half being small and recent companies.[5]

    The signatory list reads as a who’s-who of the generative stack: Anthropic, Google, Meta, Microsoft, Mistral, OpenAI, Black Forest Labs, Cohere, and Synthesia headline the provider section; Getty Images, Bulgari, Lenovo, Lufthansa, and Iberdrola appear among deployers.[5] Voluntary in name, important in practice — because the alternative to signing is proving your own measures are adequate, authority by authority, across twenty-seven member states.

    The Code’s most honest finding is technical. The Commission “has not identified any single marking or labelling technique that currently meets the AI Act’s standards,” meaning a multi-layered approach is the working requirement.[2] Concretely, the provider commitments include:

    • At least two machine-readable marking techniques for most outputs — for example, digitally signed, tamper-evident metadata plus imperceptible watermarking — with an obligation to prohibit users from stripping metadata. A single technique suffices only for free-form text (which cannot carry metadata) and for systems built into closed physical products.[2]
    • A short-text exemption with a sunset. Text under 200 tokens — roughly 150 words — is exempt from the watermarking requirement, though the Code notes the threshold may decrease as watermarking advances.[2]
    • A free detection mechanism. Providers must let third parties verify, with confidence scores, whether content came from their system — free of charge, with regulators, law enforcement, media, fact-checkers, researchers, and civil society always getting unrestricted access.[2]
    • Interoperability by February 2, 2027, so content can be verified without running each provider’s detector in turn.[2]

    On the deployer side, labels must be “immediately recognisable without user interaction, remain visible for a sufficient duration, be embedded directly into the content where possible, and be perceivable at the time of first exposure.”[2] The Commission has finalised three EU icons — for fully AI-generated content, for AI-modified content, and a basic icon with an interactive second layer — plus audible disclaimers for audio-only content where no visual label is possible.[2] The unifying principle across both sections is the same one that drives the editorial exception: disclosure has to survive the moment of consumption. A label the reader never sees, or a mark that disappears when a file is copied, is treated as no disclosure at all.

    Signatories will also be invited into two task forces launching in September 2026, tasked with sharing implementation practices and advancing the state of the art.[5] That is the Code’s real function: it converts a statutory obligation into a running technical conversation, so that the standard evolves with the technology instead of being relitigated in each enforcement case.


    What It Means for Newsrooms

    For working journalists, the rule’s effect is narrower than the headlines suggest, and larger than the letter of the law. The Media and Journalism Research Center’s implementation guide distills Article 50(4) into three sequential questions, each of which must be answered before the next is reached:[3]

    • Did an AI system generate or manipulate this text, used by the outlet under its own authority? A journalist writing unaided, or a tool used outside the organisation’s control, is outside the provision.
    • Is it published to inform the public on a matter of public interest? The Commission reads this broadly, but routine commercial text is out.
    • Did it have real human review or editorial control, and does a person or organisation hold editorial responsibility for publishing it? Review means substantive examination by someone with the judgement to do it; editorial control means authority to approve, change, or reject; editorial responsibility means someone ultimately carries legal responsibility. Fixing spelling does not count.[3]

    Only when all three conditions line up — AI under the outlet’s control, public-interest purpose, no qualifying human review — does the disclosure duty bite. In practice, newsrooms that already operate like newsrooms are largely covered: Labrador’s scenario analysis concludes that no label is needed for an AI draft substantively edited by a journalist, for AI titles and summaries edited by a journalist, or for assistive tooling like spellcheck and light retouching.[4] The outlets whose workflows actually change are the ones running automated publishing — wire-style generated coverage, SEO farms passing as news, synthetic explainers with no editor in the loop. The law’s burden lands hardest where the editorial layer is thinnest.

    The MJRC’s research design also makes an honest point that deserves to travel beyond academia: from the outside, you cannot tell compliance from silence. An article with no disclosure may simply have been written by a person, fall outside the rule, or fall within the exception — so the study commits to recording “that no disclosure was observed in the material we sampled” and never writing that AI material was unlabelled, “unless the outlet has said the material was AI generated.”[3] That is the measurement problem enforcement authorities face too, and it is why the Code leans so heavily on machine-readable marking: when visibility fails, verifiability has to carry the weight.


    What to Watch

    Four dates and one open question will decide whether this regime becomes the global default or an EU-only curiosity. The task forces launch in September 2026, where the marking standards will be refined in practice.[5] The MJRC’s first report on how newsrooms are actually implementing the rule lands in November 2026 — the first systematic look at whether outlets document editorial review or quietly relabel automation as editing.[3] December 2, 2026 closes the deferral for generative systems already on the market, and February 2, 2027 forces watermark-detection interoperability.[2] Law firms read the enforcement window the same way: as Cooley’s compliance alert puts it, “noncompliance can trigger fines of up to €15 million or 3% of worldwide annual turnover, whichever is higher.”[6]

    The open question is the direction of the editorial exception itself. It could become a floor — a documented, audited standard for what counts as editorial review that pushes every automated outlet to add humans back into the loop. Or it could become a loophole — a paperwork exercise where the “documented workflow” exists to satisfy a regulator but the machine still writes the news. The first enforcement actions against auto-publishers, and the first newsroom that loses the exception because a substantive AI edit happened after the editor signed off, will show which way the incentive really points. What is already settled is the principle: in the EU, the question “who wrote this?” now has a legal answer, and someone has to be able to prove it.


    References

    [1] European Commission — [PRIMARY] “Safer and more transparent AI.” Directorate-General for Communication. August 2, 2026.

    [2] Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison LLP — [SECONDARY] “EU Finalises Transparency Rules for AI-Generated Content.” August 4, 2026.

    [3] Media and Journalism Research Center — [SECONDARY] “Who Has to Say It Was AI? Transparency and Editorial Responsibility under Article 50(4) of the EU AI Act.” 2026.

    [4] Labrador CMS — [SECONDARY] “A Newsroom’s Survival Guide to the EU AI Act’s Article 50 Transparency Rules.” 2026.

    [5] European Commission, AI Office — [PRIMARY] “Strong Backing for the Code of Practice on Transparency of AI-Generated Content.” July 31, 2026; updated September 17, 2026.

    [6] Cooley LLP — [SECONDARY] “EU AI Act: Transparency Obligations Take Effect 2 August 2026.” August 2026.


    AI automated and generated content. Human reviewed.


    Listen to the Bears Discuss This

    Episode 28: The Editorial Test — AI Policy for the Bears

    Episode 28 of AI Policy for the Bears

  • The August 2 Convergence: How the EU, California, and New York Are Simultaneously Forging the First Mandatory AI-Content Labeling Regime

    The August 2 Convergence: How the EU, California, and New York Are Simultaneously Forging the First Mandatory AI-Content Labeling Regime

    On a single day in August 2026, three jurisdictions on two continents will switch on overlapping transparency mandates for synthetic media — and a fourth is waiting in the wings to reach into newsrooms themselves.


    One Deadline, Three Jurisdictions

    August 2, 2026 is not a symbolic date. It is the day Article 50 of the EU AI Act enters application across all 27 member states, requiring providers and deployers of AI systems to disclose AI interactions, label AI-generated content, and embed machine-readable detection marks in synthetic outputs[1]. On the same day, across the Atlantic, California’s AI Transparency Act (AB 853) takes effect, obliging generative AI providers to embed latent disclosures in AI-generated images, audio, and video, offer users a visible manifest disclosure option, and provide detection tools[2]. And roughly six weeks earlier, on June 9, 2026, New York’s synthetic performer disclosure law — the first U.S. statute to regulate AI-generated humans in advertising — went live[3].

    The simultaneity is not coincidence. California lawmakers deliberately aligned AB 853’s effective date with the EU deadline to let companies build one compliance stack for both markets[2]. The result is the first genuinely global moment for AI-content transparency: a single inflection point at which the synthetic-media free-for-all that defined 2023-2025 gives way to enforceable, penalty-backed labeling rules across a combined market of roughly 500 million people.


    The EU Framework: Four Obligations Under Article 50

    Article 50 of Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 imposes four distinct transparency duties, and crucially they apply to all AI systems used in the covered situations — not just those classified as “high-risk”[1]. This breadth is what makes Article 50 the provision likely to affect more organizations than almost any other in the Act[1]. The four obligations are:

    • Chatbot disclosure (Article 50(1)) — Providers of systems intended to interact directly with people must design them so users are informed they are interacting with AI. The logic is simple: a person cannot meaningfully consent to a conversation they do not know is synthetic, and the obligation sits on the provider by design rather than relying on each deployer to bolt on a disclaimer.
    • Machine-readable content marking (Article 50(2)) — Providers of generative AI systems producing text, images, audio, or video must mark outputs in a machine-readable format so they are detectable as artificially generated. A standardized EU label is under development. Generative AI systems already on the market before August 2, 2026 receive a grace period until December 2, 2026 for this specific marking requirement under the AI Omnibus provisional agreement[1].
    • Emotion recognition and biometric categorization notice (Article 50(3)) — Deployers of these systems must inform exposed individuals that the technology is being used. This targets workplace surveillance and retail environments where the subject may have no idea their face or voice is being analyzed.
    • Deepfake and public-interest text disclosure (Article 50(4)) — Deployers who create deepfakes must disclose that content has been artificially generated or manipulated. Separately, deployers who publish AI-generated text on matters of public interest must disclose that it is AI-generated — unless it has been subject to human review and editorial responsibility[1]. This carve-out is the provision that most directly implicates journalism: the EU framework treats human editorial review as the substitute for a label.

    To operationalize these duties, the European Commission published a Code of Practice on Transparency of AI-Generated Content, with a first draft in December 2025 and a second draft in March 2026. Although formally voluntary, the Code is designed to become the de facto compliance benchmark for providers and deployers ahead of the deadline[4]. Each EU member state designates a competent authority and market surveillance authority under Article 70 to enforce the rules[1].


    California’s CAITA: Watermarks, Detection Tools, and a 2028 Camera Mandate

    California’s AB 853 — the California AI Transparency Act, or CAITA — is the most comprehensive U.S. watermarking law, and its structure reveals a longer-term ambition than a single labeling rule. The law, which amends the earlier SB 942, takes effect August 2, 2026, with penalties of up to $5,000 per violation[2]. Its requirements escalate over three years:

    • August 2, 2026 — Generative AI providers must offer users the option to include a visible (manifest) disclosure in AI-generated image, video, or audio content; embed a detectable, latent disclosure in all AI-generated image, audio, and video content; and develop and make available tools to detect whether specified content was generated by the provider’s system[2].
    • January 1, 2027 — GenAI hosting platforms are prohibited from knowingly making available systems that do not place the required disclosures. Large online platforms must detect embedded provenance data compliant with widely adopted standards and provide a user interface disclosing its availability[2].
    • January 1, 2028 — Capture device manufacturers (cameras, mobile phones) must embed a latent disclosure in content captured by the device by default, and offer users an optional manifest disclosure[2].

    The 2028 capture-device requirement is the most architecturally significant provision. By embedding provenance at the point of capture, California is building toward a media ecosystem where the absence of a provenance signal becomes the red flag, rather than the presence of an AI label. This inverts the default: real content carries a signature, and synthetic content is what falls outside the provenance layer.


    New York’s Synthetic Performer Law: First in the Nation for Advertising

    While California built a technical provenance regime, New York targeted a specific human-likeness problem. Governor Kathy Hochul signed S.8420-A/A.8887-B into law on December 11, 2025, as Chapter 617 of the Laws of 2025, amending General Business Law Section 396-b. The law took effect June 9, 2026[3].

    The statute requires advertisers who use AI-generated “synthetic performers” — digitally created assets intended to create the impression of a human performer who is not recognizable as any identifiable natural person — to conspicuously disclose that fact. First-time violations carry a civil penalty of up to $1,000, with $5,000 for each subsequent violation[3]. The law exempts audio-only advertisements, AI-powered language translation, and promotional materials for expressive works (motion pictures, television, streaming, video games) where the synthetic performer’s use is consistent with the underlying work[5]. Section 230 protections for platforms that merely carry the advertising are expressly preserved[5].

    The law was backed by SAG-AFTRA, which framed it as a labor and consumer-protection measure. Duncan Crabtree-Ireland, the union’s National Executive Director and Chief Negotiator, said: “By mandating transparency and securing consent, New York has drawn a bright line that puts human creativity, integrity and trust first” (advocacy organization)[6]. Governor Hochul framed the stakes in direct terms: “In New York, we are setting the rules of the road instead of letting AI run the show”[3].

    The statute’s narrowness is deliberate — it covers advertising featuring synthetic human performers, not all AI-generated content — but it establishes a principle U.S. law had not previously codified: that a realistic synthetic human in commercial media carries a disclosure obligation running to the producer, not the platform.


    The Journalism Frontier: New York’s Proposed FAIR News Act

    While the synthetic performer law targets advertising, a separate New York bill would reach directly into newsrooms. Senator Patricia Fahy and Assemblymember Nily Rozic introduced the New York Fundamental Artificial Intelligence Requirements in News Act — the NY FAIR News Act — in early 2026[7]. The bill would require news organizations to place disclaimers on published content that is “substantially composed, authored, or created through the use of generative artificial intelligence,” and to mandate human review by an employee “with editorial control” before any AI-assisted content is published[7].

    The bill goes further than disclosure. It would require news organizations to disclose to journalists how AI is being used in the newsroom, create safeguards protecting confidential source material from AI access, and include labor protections restricting the firing or pay-cutting of journalists due to generative AI adoption[7]. Assemblymember Rozic framed the legislation in terms of New York’s media-sector centrality: “At the center of the news industry, New York has a strong interest in preserving journalism and protecting the workers who produce it”[7]. Senator Fahy cited public-opinion data, noting that “more than 76% of Americans are concerned about AI stealing or reproducing journalism and local news stories”[7].

    The bill drew endorsements from WGA-East, SAG-AFTRA, the DGA, and the NewsGuild of New York, which had launched a nationwide “News Not Slop” campaign in December 2025 to advocate for AI guardrails in newsrooms[7]. A notable carve-out: copyrightable material can be excluded from the law’s scope, leveraging the U.S. Copyright Office’s position that works solely generated by AI are not copyright-eligible but works showing “human authorship” are[7]. This ties the disclosure obligation to a legal boundary that already exists in copyright doctrine — if a human authored enough to hold a copyright, the statute presumes a human was editorially responsible.


    The Federal Preemption Shadow

    U.S. state disclosure laws are taking effect against a backdrop of explicit federal hostility. On December 11, 2025 — the same day Governor Hochul signed New York’s synthetic performer law — President Trump issued an executive order declaring “a minimally burdensome national policy framework for AI” and proposing to preempt state AI laws deemed inconsistent with that policy[8]. The order directs the FCC to initiate a proceeding on a federal AI reporting and disclosure standard that would preempt conflicting state laws, and directs the FTC to issue a policy statement by March 11, 2026, on when state laws requiring alteration of truthful outputs are preempted by federal deception law[8].

    Colorado’s SB 24-205 is the only state law specifically named in the executive order, but the timing — issued the same day as New York’s signing and weeks before California’s and Texas’s laws took effect January 1, 2026 — signals broader targets[8]. The order identifies categories of regulation not proposed for preemption, including child safety, AI compute infrastructure, and state government procurement and use of AI[8]. Notably, content disclosure and transparency mandates are not listed among the protected categories.

    Whether preemption will hold is a question for the courts. King & Spalding’s analysis concludes that “it will fall to the courts to determine if, whether and how the Executive Order will affect multiple state AI laws,” and advises companies to maintain flexible compliance programs capable of adjusting to the shifting state and federal environment[8]. The practical effect in the short term is that the August 2 state mandates are proceeding on schedule while the federal challenge works through the legal system — meaning organizations face real, penalty-backed obligations now, with the possibility of regulatory relief later.


    What the Convergence Means for the Media Ecosystem

    The August 2 deadline matters because it ends the voluntary era. Through 2025, AI-content labeling was largely a matter of platform policy — TikTok required labeling for realistic AI content, YouTube required disclosure for synthetic content that appears real, and individual publishers adopted their own standards[5]. After August 2, 2026, labeling becomes a legal obligation backed by civil penalties in jurisdictions covering most of the developed media market.

    For the media and information ecosystem, three dynamics are worth tracking:

    • Provenance infrastructure becomes a compliance asset. California’s 2028 capture-device mandate and the EU’s machine-readable marking requirement point toward a provenance layer built into content at the point of creation. Organizations that invest in C2PA-compatible provenance tooling now will be positioned to satisfy both regimes with one technical investment. The alternative — building separate disclosure systems for each jurisdiction — is more expensive and more fragile as new laws arrive.
    • The journalism carve-out becomes the battleground. Both the EU (Article 50(4)’s human-review exemption) and the proposed NY FAIR News Act treat human editorial review as the substitute for a label. The political and legal fight will be over what counts as “editorial control” — a light human edit, a substantive review, or full authorship. News organizations that build documented review workflows will be better positioned to rely on the carve-out, while those that publish AI text with minimal human involvement will face the labeling obligation.
    • Federal preemption creates compliance bifurcation risk. If the FCC or FTC succeeds in establishing a federal disclosure standard that preempts state law, companies that built compliance around California’s specific latent-disclosure requirements may need to rebuild. The safest path is to comply with the most stringent applicable state regime now while building modular systems that can adapt to a federal standard if one arrives.

    The broader signal is that the synthetic-media transparency question has moved from “should we label?” to “how do we label at scale?” The August 2 convergence answers the first question definitively. The second is now the engineering and policy challenge of the next two years.


    References

    [1] **[PRIMARY]** European Union. “The EU AI Act’s Transparency Rules: A Practical Guide to Article 50.” *artificialintelligenceact.eu*. May 14, 2026. https://artificialintelligenceact.eu/transparency-rules-article-50/

    [2] **[SECONDARY]** AI Laws by State. “AI Disclosure & Transparency Laws by State 2026.” *ailawsbystate.com*. 2026. https://www.ailawsbystate.com/tools/ai-disclosure-tracker

    [3] **[SECONDARY]** Bonavita, Julia. “New York law requires clear disclosure labels on AI-generated ads.” *Fox News*. 2026. https://www.foxnews.com/media/new-york-makes-history-first-of-its-kind-law-regulating-ai-powered-commercials

    [4] **[PRIMARY]** European Commission. “Code of Practice on Transparency of AI-Generated Content.” *digital-strategy.ec.europa.eu*. 2026. https://digital-strategy.ec.europa.eu/en/policies/code-practice-ai-generated-content

    [5] **[SECONDARY]** Dynamis LLP. “AI Disclosure in 2026: Recent Developments and Practical Steps for Brands and Influencers.” *dynamisllp.com*. 2026. https://www.dynamisllp.com/knowledge/ai-disclosure-in-2026-recent-developments-and-practical-steps-for-brands-and-influencers

    [6] **[ADVOCACY]** SAG-AFTRA. “Gov. Hochul Signs Union-Backed AI Bills.” *sagaftra.org*. 2025. https://www.sagaftra.org/gov-hochul-signs-union-backed-ai-bills-sag-aftra-new-york-office

    [7] **[SECONDARY]** Deck, Andrew. “A new bill in New York would require disclaimers on AI-generated news content.” *Nieman Journalism Lab, Harvard University*. February 5, 2026. https://www.niemanlab.org/2026/02/a-new-bill-in-new-york-would-require-disclaimers-on-ai-generated-news-content/

    [8] **[SECONDARY]** Lasater, Dirk D. “New State AI Laws are Effective on January 1, 2026, But a New Executive Order Signals Disruption.” *King & Spalding*. December 29, 2025. https://www.kslaw.com/news-and-insights/new-state-ai-laws-are-effective-on-january-1-2026-but-a-new-executive-order-signals-disruption


    AI automated and generated content. Human reviewed.

  • The Federal-State Collision Over AI Hiring Regulation

    The Federal-State Collision Over AI Hiring Regulation

    The Trump administration’s Executive Order 14365 aims to sweep away state AI hiring laws in the name of national dominance, even as states from California to New Jersey accelerate their own regulations and a landmark lawsuit against Workday tests whether AI vendors can be sued as employers.


    The Federal Retreat

    The federal government’s approach to AI in employment has reversed course entirely since January 2025. Under the Biden administration, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission launched its Initiative on Artificial Intelligence and Algorithmic Fairness in 2021, issued technical guidance in 2023 applying Title VII principles to AI-assisted hiring, and filed amicus briefs supporting plaintiffs in emerging AI discrimination cases.[1] That infrastructure is now gone.

    On January 20, 2025, President Trump revoked Biden’s executive order on the safe and trustworthy development of AI. Three days later, Executive Order 14179 directed federal agencies to review and roll back existing AI policies and regulations.[2] The EEOC removed its 2023 guidance on responsible AI use in employment selection from its website, the Department of Labor’s OFCCP retracted AI and equal employment opportunity guidance for federal contractors, and the agency deprioritized enforcement of disparate impact theories of liability.[2][3]

    On April 23, 2025, Executive Order 14281, titled “Restoring Equality of Opportunity and Meritocracy,” went further, disavowing federal reliance on disparate impact liability “in all contexts to the maximum degree possible” and directing agencies to deprioritize enforcement of disparate impact statutes and regulations.[4] The Biden-era EEOC guidance for employers using AI no longer exists as an enforceable reference point. As Fisher Phillips noted, no federal AI workplace law is expected from the Republican-controlled Congress in 2025 or 2026.[5]


    EO 14365: The Preemption offensive

    The administration’s most aggressive move came on December 11, 2025, with Executive Order 14365, “Ensuring a National Policy Framework for Artificial Intelligence.” The order frames state-level AI regulation as the primary threat to American AI innovation, arguing that “a patchwork of 50 different regulatory regimes” makes compliance more challenging, particularly for startups.[6]

    The order’s language is unusually pointed for a presidential directive. It specifically calls out a Colorado law banning algorithmic discrimination, warning that such laws “may even force AI models to produce false results in order to avoid a ‘differential treatment or impact’ on protected groups.”[6] This is a striking claim: it treats bias mitigation as a form of compelled falsification rather than a civil rights safeguard. The underlying logic is that any regulation requiring AI outputs to account for demographic disparities amounts to government-mandated distortion of truthful results — a framing that puts anti-discrimination law and free-market AI development in direct opposition.

    EO 14365 establishes several enforcement mechanisms:

    • AI Litigation Task Force: Within 30 days, the Attorney General was directed to establish a task force to challenge state AI laws on grounds including unconstitutional regulation of interstate commerce and federal preemption. The task force was formally established on January 9, 2026, but no litigation has been initiated as of mid-2026.[7]
    • Commerce Department evaluation: Within 90 days, the Secretary of Commerce was to publish an evaluation identifying state laws requiring AI models to alter truthful outputs or compelling disclosures that violate the First Amendment. This evaluation was not publicly available by its March 2026 deadline.[7]
    • Funding conditions: States with “onerous” AI laws may be deemed ineligible for non-deployment funds under the BEAD broadband program, and federal agencies may condition discretionary grants on states agreeing not to enact or enforce conflicting AI laws.[6]
    • FCC and FTC proceedings: The FCC Chairman was directed to initiate a proceeding on a federal reporting and disclosure standard that would preempt conflicting state laws, and the FTC Chairman was to issue a policy statement on preemption of state laws mandating what the administration calls “deceptive conduct.” Neither action had been taken by mid-2026.[7]

    The pattern is notable: the executive order sets ambitious deadlines, but agency implementation has lagged. As the employment law firm Law and the Workplace observed, the order “does not immediately impact existing AI laws but establishes a process to discourage, challenge, and potentially preempt them.”[7] Employers remain obligated to comply with state and local AI laws in the meantime.


    States Fill the Void

    Even as the federal government retreats, states are accelerating. The National Conference of State Legislatures reports that all 50 states, Puerto Rico, the U.S. Virgin Islands, and Washington, D.C. introduced AI-related legislation in 2025, with approximately 100 measures adopted across 38 states.[8] Several of the most consequential state-level moves in the employment domain occurred in late 2025 and early 2026:

    • California: In October 2025, the Civil Rights Council enacted regulations making it unlawful to use automated decision systems or selection criteria that discriminate against applicants or employees — or a class of applicants or employees — based on protected characteristics under the Fair Employment and Housing Act.[1] Separately, California’s CCPA automated decision-making technology (ADMT) rules take effect January 1, 2027, requiring pre-use notice, opt-out rights, and access to information about how ADMT is used in significant employment decisions.[9]
    • New Jersey: In December 2025, the Division on Civil Rights adopted administrative code clarifying that employers may face liability for “algorithmic discrimination” even without discriminatory intent, and even when relying on third-party developers. The regulations provide examples of violations, including AI tools that use current employee populations as baselines for candidate searches or that screen candidates based on availability.[1]
    • Illinois: Effective January 1, 2026, the Human Rights Act was amended by statute to codify as a civil rights violation the use of AI in changing terms or conditions of employment if it subjects a person to discrimination based on protected characteristics, and it prohibits using ZIP codes as a proxy for protected characteristics.[1]
    • Connecticut: On February 25, 2026, the Attorney General’s Office issued a memo invoking existing state anti-discrimination laws as applicable to AI in hiring and employment. Pending Senate Bill 435 would impose disclosure requirements, bias audits by government-approved third parties, and mandatory human review of automated employment decisions.[1]
    • Colorado: The state’s AI Act, effective for employment obligations on January 1, 2027, requires businesses to provide descriptions of ADMT’s role in adverse decisions within 30 days, offer opportunities for human review, and allow requests for corrections to factually incorrect personal data.[9]

    The core logic driving these state efforts is that existing civil rights protections do not vanish simply because a decision is made by an algorithm rather than a human. As the joint statement from the EEOC, DOJ, CFPB, and FTC put it in April 2023, “There is no AI exemption to the laws on the books.”[5] State regulators are applying that principle: they are not creating new protected categories but clarifying that old ones — race, sex, age, disability — apply when the decision-maker is a machine learning model. The disagreement with the federal government is not over whether discrimination is wrong, but over whether algorithmic bias counts as discrimination in the first place.


    Mobley v. Workday: The Defining Test Case

    While legislators and executive branch officials argue over the regulatory framework, the courts are quietly building the case law that may matter most. Derek L. Mobley v. Workday, Inc., pending in the Northern District of California, is the highest-profile test of whether AI hiring tools can produce liability under existing anti-discrimination statutes.[10]

    The lead plaintiff, Derek Mobley, is an African American man over age 40 who alleges depression and anxiety as disabilities under the ADA Amendments Act. He claims that since at least 2017, he applied for over 100 positions through employers using Workday’s platform and was rejected for every application.[10] Three additional named plaintiffs have joined, each bringing claims based on their own rejections through Workday-powered systems.

    The case turns on a question that could reshape the entire AI hiring industry: can an AI vendor be treated as an “employer” under federal anti-discrimination law? Workday argued it was not an employer and therefore not subject to liability. The court rejected that argument, finding the complaint adequately alleged that Workday is an agent of its client-employers, falling within the definition of “employer” under Title VII, the ADEA, and the ADA.[10] On May 16, 2025, the court granted preliminary certification of a collective action on the ADEA claim.[11]

    The plaintiffs’ theory of how bias enters AI hiring systems is particularly important for policy. They argue that bias creeps in through training data composition, the selection and weighting of input variables, the design of model objectives, and the evaluation criteria used to assess candidate “fit.”[10] Even where protected characteristics are not explicitly provided to the system, they can be inferred through proxy variables: employment gaps may reflect disability, years of experience may stand in for age, educational background may correlate with race, and application data may encode gender or caregiving responsibilities.[10] This is the mechanism that makes algorithmic discrimination both pervasive and hard to detect — and it is the reason state laws like Illinois’s ban on ZIP code proxies and New Jersey’s prohibition on using current employee populations as baselines target specific technical practices rather than abstract harms.

    The political context has shifted under the case. Under the Biden administration, the EEOC filed amicus briefs supporting the plaintiffs. Under the Trump administration, that guidance was removed from the EEOC website and the agency deprioritized disparate impact cases.[10] But the case continues regardless — individual litigants are not restricted from pursuing disparate impact claims, even when the federal government declines to participate.[10]


    A New Legal Theory: FCRA and the Consumer Report Problem

    Beyond disparate impact, a new theory of liability for AI hiring tools emerged in January 2026. A nationally recognized plaintiffs’ employment class action firm filed a putative class action against an AI recruiting and “talent intelligence” technology company, alleging that the company assembles public information about candidates from across the web to create a proprietary database, then sells prospective employers reports to evaluate candidates — creating and selling “consumer reports” without complying with applicable laws.[1]

    The claims asserted include violations of the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act, California’s Investigative Consumer Reporting Agencies Act, and California’s Unfair Competition Law.[1] This represents an entirely new theory for challenging pre-employment AI tools: rather than arguing that the algorithm discriminates, the plaintiffs argue that the entire business model of scraping and selling candidate data triggers a federal disclosure and consent regime that most AI hiring companies have never considered. If successful, this approach would force AI hiring vendors into the same compliance framework that governs traditional background check companies — a potentially far-reaching expansion of liability that does not depend on disparate impact doctrine at all.


    What Comes Next

    The federal-state collision over AI hiring regulation is unlikely to resolve cleanly. Several dynamics will shape the next phase:

    • State enforcement will proceed regardless of federal posture. State attorneys general and civil rights agencies have their own enforcement authority, and states with private rights of action — like California, New Jersey, and Illinois — give individual plaintiffs the power to bring cases even when federal regulators sit on the sidelines.[1]
    • The preemption fight will move to the courts. EO 14365’s AI Litigation Task Force has not yet filed suits, but the legal arguments — dormant commerce clause, field preemption, conflict preemption — will take years to litigate. In the meantime, state laws remain in effect.[7]
    • Mobley v. Workday could establish vendor liability. If the court ultimately holds that AI hiring vendors are “employers” under Title VII, the ADA, and the ADEA, every company that sells AI screening tools faces potential exposure to the full range of employment discrimination claims.[10]
    • The FCRA theory expands the attack surface. By pulling AI hiring tools into the consumer reporting framework, plaintiffs’ attorneys have found a path that bypasses the disparate impact debate entirely — one that does not depend on proving bias, only on proving that the vendor failed to follow disclosure and consent requirements.[1]

    The underlying tension is structural. The federal government wants a single, minimally burdensome national standard to preserve American AI competitiveness. States want to protect their residents from algorithmic discrimination using tools that already exist in their legal codes. And employers are caught between two authorities pulling in opposite directions — one telling them to innovate freely, the other telling them to audit, disclose, and explain. The resolution will likely come not from legislation or executive orders, but from the slow accumulation of court decisions that define what AI vendors owe the people whose careers their algorithms shape.


    References

    [1] [SECONDARY] Signs, Christiana L. and Romeo, Samuel. “State AI Hiring Tool Regulations Filling Federal Void.” Reed Smith Employment Law Watch. April 22, 2026. https://www.reedsmith.com/our-insights/blogs/employment-law-watch/102mqfg/state-ai-hiring-tool-regulations-filling-federal-void/

    [2] [SECONDARY] Lada, Jennifer; Chapman, D’Andre; and Askinazi, Laura. “Artificial Intelligence in Hiring: Diverging Federal, State Perspectives on AI in Employment.” Holland & Knight Alert. March 20, 2025. https://www.hklaw.com/en/insights/publications/2025/03/artificial-intelligence-in-hiring-diverging-federal-state-perspectives

    [3] [SECONDARY] Meneghello, Richard R. and Walton, David J. “Comprehensive Review of AI Workplace Law and Litigation as We Enter 2025.” Fisher Phillips Insights. January 3, 2025. https://www.fisherphillips.com/en/insights/insights/comprehensive-review-of-ai-workplace-law-and-litigation-as-we-enter-2025

    [4] [PRIMARY] Trump, Donald J. “Executive Order 14281 — Restoring Equality of Opportunity and Meritocracy.” Federal Register. April 23, 2025. https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2025/04/29/2025-07389/restoring-equality-of-opportunity-and-meritocracy

    [5] [SECONDARY] Meneghello, Richard R. and Walton, David J. “Comprehensive Review of AI Workplace Law and Litigation as We Enter 2025.” Fisher Phillips Insights. January 3, 2025. https://www.fisherphillips.com/en/insights/insights/comprehensive-review-of-ai-workplace-law-and-litigation-as-we-enter-2025

    [6] [PRIMARY] Trump, Donald J. “Executive Order 14365 — Ensuring a National Policy Framework for Artificial Intelligence.” Federal Register. December 11, 2025. https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2025/12/16/2025-23092/ensuring-a-national-policy-framework-for-artificial-intelligence

    [7] [SECONDARY] “What President Trump’s AI Executive Order 14365 Means For Employers.” Law and the Workplace. April 2026. https://www.lawandtheworkplace.com/2026/04/what-president-trumps-ai-executive-order-14365-means-for-employers/

    [8] [PRIMARY] National Conference of State Legislatures. “Artificial Intelligence 2025 Legislation.” NCSL. July 10, 2025. https://www.ncsl.org/technology-and-communication/artificial-intelligence-2025-legislation

    [9] [SECONDARY] “AI Hiring Regulations: New State Laws, Risks & Compliance Guide (2026–2027).” SynHr. 2026. https://synhr.com/ai-hiring-regulations/

    [10] [SECONDARY] Edmondson, Elizabeth. “Emerging Liability for AI-Driven Hiring Tools: Key Developments in Mobley v. Workday, Inc.” Maynard Nexsen. April 23, 2026. https://www.maynardnexsen.com/publication-emerging-liability-for-ai-driven-hiring-tools-key-developments-in-mobley-v-workday-inc

    [11] [SECONDARY] “AI Bias Lawsuit Against Workday Reaches Next Stage as Court Grants Conditional Certification of ADEA Claim.” Law and the Workplace. June 2025. https://www.lawandtheworkplace.com/2025/06/ai-bias-lawsuit-against-workday-reaches-next-stage-as-court-grants-conditional-certification-of-adea-claim/


    AI automated and generated content. Human reviewed.

  • The Trump AI Executive Order: Removing Barriers to American Leadership

    The Trump AI Executive Order: “Removing Barriers to American Leadership”

    Signed January 23, 2025, this executive order rescinds Biden’s EO 14110 and pivots U.S. federal AI policy from a risk-management posture to an innovation-first, deregulatory approach.

    What Changed

    President Trump’s executive order, titled “Removing Barriers to American Leadership in Artificial Intelligence,” represents a sharp reversal from the Biden administration’s EO 14110 (October 2023). Key shifts:

    What Was Rescinded

    Biden’s EO 14110 had established:

    • Extensive safety testing requirements for frontier AI models (above a compute threshold)
    • Red-team testing and reporting obligations for dual-use foundation models
    • Federal agency AI governance requirements (Chief AI Officers, AI use case inventories)
    • Immigration provisions to attract AI talent
    • Standards for AI in federal procurement

    The Trump EO rescinded these requirements, calling them “Barriers to American Leadership.”

    What Was Kept or Added

    • Support for the U.S. AI Safety Institute (USAISI) — maintained, though with a revised mission focused on “promoting AI innovation”
    • A directive to develop an AI Action Plan within 180 days (by July 2025)
    • Review of all federal agency actions taken under Biden’s EO to identify and remove “undue burdens”
    • Commitment to maintain U.S. dominance in AI development

    The Policy Shift

    The contrast between the two administrations is stark:

    Dimension Biden EO 14110 Trump EO (Jan 2025)
    Posture Risk management, safety-first Innovation-first, deregulatory
    Frontier models Mandatory safety testing, reporting No mandatory testing
    Agency governance Chief AI Officers, inventories Review and remove “undue burdens”
    International engagement Aligned with Bletchley Declaration America-first framing

    Implications for AI Policy

    The Trump EO creates significant uncertainty for organizations that had begun implementing compliance programs under Biden’s EO:

    • Companies that established red-team testing and safety reporting protocols may no longer be required to use them
    • The NIST AI RMF remains voluntary but may receive less federal promotion
    • State-level laws like Colorado’s AI Act and NYC Local Law 144 become more important as federal requirements recede
    • The EU AI Act (Regulation 2024/1689) now stands as the world’s most comprehensive binding AI regulation, potentially creating a “Brussels Effect” where global companies default to EU compliance standards

    Primary Sources


    AI automated and generated content. Human reviewed. All policy text is summarized from the primary sources linked above.

  • The Bletchley Declaration: 28 Nations Agree on AI Safety Priorities

    The Bletchley Declaration: 28 Nations Agree on AI Safety Priorities

    Signed at the AI Safety Summit on November 2, 2023, at Bletchley Park (the historic site of WWII codebreaking), the Bletchley Declaration established the first international consensus on AI safety risks and the need for collaborative governance.

    What It Says

    The Bletchley Declaration was signed by representatives of 28 countries including the United States, United Kingdom, China, the European Union, India, and others. It represents the first time so many nations formally acknowledged the need for international cooperation on AI safety.

    Key commitments in the Declaration include:

    1. Identifying AI Safety Risks of Shared Concern

    The Declaration identifies “frontier AI” (highly capable general-purpose AI models) as a category requiring special attention, noting risks including unintended consequences, loss of control, and potential misuse for harm at scale.

    2. Building a Shared Scientific Evidence Base

    Signatories committed to supporting “an internationally inclusive network of scientific research on frontier AI safety” — leading to the establishment of AI Safety Institutes in the UK, US, and other countries.

    3. Developing Risk-Based Policies

    The Declaration acknowledges that different countries may adopt different approaches but emphasizes the need for policies that are “interoperable” across jurisdictions — a principle also embedded in the EU AI Act‘s risk-based framework.

    What Followed

    The Bletchley Declaration spawned a series of follow-on summits:

    • Seoul AI Summit (May 2024): 16 companies committed to voluntary AI safety frameworks
    • UK AI Safety Institute: Established November 2023, the first government-backed institute dedicated to evaluating advanced AI systems
    • US AI Safety Institute (USAISI): Established through the NIST, works with the UK institute on shared evaluation methodologies

    Significance

    The Bletchley Declaration is significant for several reasons:

    • China’s participation: Despite geopolitical tensions, China signed the Declaration — a rare moment of US-China-EU alignment on technology policy
    • Focus on “frontier AI”: The Declaration was the first major international statement to specifically call out frontier models as a distinct risk category
    • Institutional legacy: It directly led to the creation of national AI Safety Institutes, which are now the primary government bodies evaluating advanced AI systems

    How It Relates to Other Frameworks

    The Bletchley Declaration is a diplomatic statement, not a binding regulation. It complements:

    • The EU AI Act — binding regulation with risk tiers
    • The NIST AI RMF — voluntary U.S. framework
    • The Trump administration’s AI EO (January 2025) — which rescinded Biden’s EO 14110 but maintained support for AI Safety Institute work

    Primary Sources


    AI automated and generated content. Human reviewed. All policy text is summarized from the primary sources linked above.

  • Utah SB 149: First State Law Regulating AI in K-12 Education

    Utah SB 149: First State Law Regulating AI in K-12 Education

    Utah’s Artificial Intelligence Policy for K-12 Education Act, signed March 2024, requires school districts to adopt policies governing student AI use, mandates AI literacy instruction, and establishes guardrails for AI tools used in educational settings.

    What the Law Requires

    Utah SB 149, the Artificial Intelligence Policy for K-12 Education Act, was the first state law specifically targeting AI use in public K-12 classrooms. Key provisions include:

    School District AI Policies

    • Each school district and charter school must adopt a policy governing the use of AI by students and educators
    • Policies must address acceptable use, academic integrity, data privacy, and age-appropriate restrictions
    • Policies must be reviewed and updated at least every two years

    AI Literacy Requirements

    • The State Board of Education must develop AI literacy standards for students
    • AI literacy must be integrated into existing curriculum — not as a standalone course requirement, but woven into relevant subjects
    • “AI literacy” is defined as the ability to understand, use, and evaluate AI tools critically

    Vendor and Tool Requirements

    • AI tools used in schools must comply with existing student data privacy laws (FERPA, COPPA)
    • AI tools must not collect or use student data beyond what is necessary for the educational purpose
    • Schools must disclose to parents when AI tools are used in their child’s education

    Why Utah Went First

    Utah has positioned itself as a leader in AI policy. The state also created the Artificial Intelligence Policy Act (SB 149 companion legislation) establishing the state’s AI Policy Office and an AI policy liaison. Utah’s approach is notably more prescriptive than other states’ — it mandates specific actions (policy adoption, literacy standards) rather than just prohibiting harmful uses.

    How It Compares

    Other states have addressed AI in education through guidance rather than legislation:

    • California: The Department of Education published AI guidance for schools but has not enacted a law equivalent to SB 149
    • EU AI Act: Classifies AI systems used in education as “high-risk” (Annex III), requiring conformity assessment and risk management — but does not mandate AI literacy curriculum specifically

    Primary Sources


    AI automated and generated content. Human reviewed. All policy text is summarized from the primary sources linked above.

  • NYC Local Law 144: The First Mandatory AI Bias Audit Law in the United States

    NYC Local Law 144: The First Mandatory AI Bias Audit Law in the United States

    Since July 5, 2023, employers in New York City using automated employment decision tools (AEDTs) to screen candidates or employees must commission annual independent bias audits and publish the results — the first U.S. law to mandate algorithmic auditing of hiring tools.

    What the Law Requires

    NYC Local Law 144, passed in December 2021 and effective July 5, 2023, requires that:

    1. An employer or employment agency may not use an automated employment decision tool (AEDT) to screen a candidate or employee for employment unless the tool has been subject to an annual independent bias audit.
    2. The results of the bias audit must be published on the employer’s website.
    3. Candidates and employees must be notified at least 10 business days before the AEDT is used, including information about the data sources used, the qualifications assessed, and the retention period.

    What Counts as an AEDT

    An AEDT is defined as any computational process derived from machine learning, statistical modeling, data analytics, or artificial intelligence that:

    • Issues a simplified output (score, tag, classification, recommendation) AND
    • Is designed to substantially assist or replace discretionary decision-making in hiring

    Notably, the final rules clarified that a tool “substantially assists” decision-making if it relies on a score or ranking to select candidates, even if a human reviews the results. This addresses the “human-in-the-loop” question — a rubber-stamp review does not exempt the tool from the audit requirement.

    The Bias Audit

    The independent audit must evaluate the tool’s selection rates across protected categories (sex, race/ethnicity) and calculate impact ratios in compliance with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission’s Uniform Guidelines on Employee Selection Procedures (29 C.F.R. § 1607). The audit must include:

    • The number and demographic categories of individuals the tool assessed
    • Selection rates for each demographic category
    • Impact ratios comparing selection rates across categories
    • The distribution of candidates across categories

    Enforcement

    The NYC Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP) enforces the law. Violations carry civil penalties of:

    • $500 for the first violation
    • $500–$1,500 for each subsequent violation (per day)

    The law does not provide a private right of action.

    How It Compares

    Local Law 144 is narrower than Colorado’s AI Act (SB 24-205), which covers all high-risk AI systems — not just hiring tools — and requires impact assessments and risk management plans. But Local Law 144 is more specific in its audit requirements: it mandates an independent third-party audit, while Colorado’s law allows self-assessment.

    The EU AI Act similarly classifies AI systems used in employment as “high-risk” (Annex III), requiring conformity assessments, risk management systems, and human oversight — but does not mandate independent bias audits in the same way.

    Primary Sources


    AI automated and generated content. Human reviewed. All policy text is summarized from the primary sources linked above.

  • FDA Framework for AI/ML-Enabled Medical Devices: Predetermined Change Control Plans

    FDA Framework for AI/ML-Enabled Medical Devices: Predetermined Change Control Plans

    The FDA’s approach to regulating AI/ML-enabled medical devices centers on a “total product lifecycle” framework and the concept of Predetermined Change Control Plans (PCCPs), allowing approved devices to evolve after market authorization without requiring new submissions for every update.

    The Framework

    The U.S. Food and Drug Administration regulates AI/ML-enabled software that meets the definition of a medical device under the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act. As of 2025, the FDA has cleared or authorized more than 950 AI/ML-enabled medical devices through the 510(k), De Novo, and PMA pathways.

    The agency’s regulatory framework is built around several key guidance documents and concepts:

    Predetermined Change Control Plans (PCCPs)

    A PCCP allows a manufacturer to describe in their initial submission what types of modifications they plan to make to the AI/ML algorithm after deployment — such as retraining with new data or adjusting model parameters. If the FDA approves the PCCP, the manufacturer can implement those specific changes without filing a new submission for each update.

    This is a significant departure from the traditional medical device model, where any modification requires a new 510(k) or supplement. The FDA recognized that AI/ML algorithms are inherently iterative — they learn and adapt — and a traditional regulatory framework would stifle clinically beneficial improvements.

    Good Machine Learning Practice (GMLP)

    The FDA, in collaboration with Health Canada and the UK’s MHRA, published a set of Good Machine Learning Practice guiding principles in October 2021. These 10 principles cover:

    • Applying software engineering and quality system practices throughout the product lifecycle
    • Clinically robust training and testing datasets that reflect the intended patient population
    • Independent review of training data by qualified experts
    • Device performance monitoring and iterative improvement

    Transparency and Bias

    The FDA has emphasized the importance of transparency in AI/ML devices, particularly regarding:

    • How the device’s inputs and outputs should be interpreted
    • Limitations and contraindications
    • Populations for which the device has been tested and validated
    • Potential for bias if the training data does not represent the intended use population

    Relationship to EU AI Act

    Under the EU AI Act, most AI-enabled medical devices are classified as “high-risk” AI systems and are subject to conformity assessment requirements before being placed on the EU market. This includes risk management systems, data governance, technical documentation, and human oversight requirements. The FDA framework, by contrast, operates through device-specific clearance pathways rather than a horizontal AI-specific regulation.

    Primary Sources


    AI automated and generated content. Human reviewed. All policy text is summarized from the primary sources linked above.

  • California Cracks Down on AI Deepfakes in Elections with Trio of Laws

    California Cracks Down on AI Deepfakes in Elections with Trio of Laws

    Three bills signed by Governor Gavin Newsom in September 2024 target AI-generated deepfakes in political advertising, election communications, and campaign materials — the most aggressive state-level response to election-related synthetic media.

    AB 2655 — Defending Democracy from Deepfakes Act

    The most expansive of the three, AB 2655 prohibits the distribution of materially deceptive audio or visual media of elected officials, candidates, and election officials within 120 days before an election. “Materially deceptive” means a reasonable person would believe it’s authentic and it could harm the subject’s reputation or electoral prospects.

    The law also requires large online platforms (defined as those with at least 1 million California monthly users) to:

    • Remove or label reported deepfakes within specified timeframes
    • Provide a reporting mechanism for flagged content
    • Maintain publicly accessible lists of removed deepfake material

    AB 730 — Election Deepfakes (Communications)

    AB 730 makes it unlawful to distribute within 60 days before an election any deceptive audio or visual media of a candidate that is intended to injure their reputation or deceive voters. The law includes exemptions for parody, satire, and content that includes a prominent disclosure label.

    AB 2839 — Manipulated Media in Campaign Communications

    AB 2839 prohibits the distribution of campaign communications containing materially deceptive images, audio, or video of a candidate that knowingly deceives voters — expanded from a prior law that only covered audio. Notably, this law applies year-round, not just before elections.

    First Amendment Challenges

    Several of these laws face constitutional challenges. In Bloomberg et al. v. Bowen and related cases, plaintiffs argue the laws violate the First Amendment’s protections for political speech, parody, and satire. A federal judge granted a preliminary injunction blocking enforcement of AB 2839 in October 2024 against a plaintiff who posted a manipulated video of Vice President Harris, finding the law likely violated the First Amendment.

    Context

    These California laws are part of a broader wave of state-level deepfake legislation. Texas SB 751, passed in 2023, similarly criminalizes the creation and distribution of deepfake videos intended to influence elections. The EU AI Act also addresses deepfakes, requiring providers of AI systems that generate synthetic media to disclose that content is AI-generated.

    Primary Sources


    AI automated and generated content. Human reviewed. All policy text is summarized from the primary sources linked above.

  • Colorado Becomes First State to Pass Comprehensive AI Anti-Discrimination Law

    Colorado Becomes First State to Pass Comprehensive AI Anti-Discrimination Law

    SB 24-205, signed by Governor Jared Polis in May 2024, takes effect February 1, 2026. It is the first U.S. state law to impose affirmative obligations on developers and deployers of “high-risk” artificial intelligence systems.

    What the Law Requires

    Colorado’s Artificial Intelligence Act (Senate Bill 24-205) establishes a duty of care for anyone who develops or deploys a “high-risk AI system” — defined as any AI system that makes, or is a substantial factor in making, a “consequential decision” affecting a consumer. Consequential decisions include those related to employment, financial services, housing, insurance, government benefits, healthcare, legal services, and education.

    The law imposes two separate sets of obligations:

    For Developers

    • Exercise reasonable care to avoid algorithmic discrimination
    • Provide deployers with a statement of dependencies documenting the system’s intended uses, known limitations, and data governance practices
    • Conduct and document impact assessments of the system
    • Make disclosures available to the Colorado Attorney General upon request

    For Deployers

    • Exercise reasonable care to avoid algorithmic discrimination
    • Conduct an impact assessment before deploying the system
    • Implement a risk management plan — which may be based on the NIST AI Risk Management Framework (NIST AI RMF 1.0, published January 2023)
    • Notify consumers when they are interacting with an AI system (where applicable)
    • Provide consumers with an adverse action notice if an AI system was a substantial factor in a denial decision

    Enforcement

    The Colorado Attorney General has exclusive enforcement authority. There is no private right of action under the law. Violations are treated as deceptive trade practices under the Colorado Consumer Protection Act. The AG may also require developers and deployers to provide documentation of their impact assessments and risk management programs.

    How It Compares

    Colorado’s law is modeled on the EU AI Act (Regulation 2024/1689), which similarly categorizes AI systems by risk level and imposes obligations on high-risk systems. However, unlike the EU AI Act, Colorado’s law does not ban any AI uses outright and provides no private right of action.

    It also differs from New York City Local Law 144, which regulates automated employment decision tools (AEDTs) specifically and requires annual independent bias audits — a requirement Colorado’s law does not include.

    Timeline

    • May 17, 2024: Signed by Governor Polis (who expressed concerns about competitiveness and signed with a statement urging future amendments)
    • February 1, 2026: Law takes effect

    Primary Sources


    AI automated and generated content. Human reviewed. All policy text is summarized from the primary sources linked above.