The Rules That Never Came: How a January Deadline, an Eighteen-Day Rulemaking, and a Vanishing Web Page Left Illinois Employers Guessing at AI Notice
Illinois HB 3773 has made undisclosed AI use in employment decisions a civil rights violation since January 1, 2026. The state agency charged with writing the implementing rules published them on May 15, withdrew them eighteen days later, and has not refiled — so employers must work out what compliant notice looks like while the duty itself is already enforceable.
A Statute That Went Live Without Its Manual
On August 9, 2024, Governor J.B. Pritzker signed House Bill 3773, making Illinois the second state in the country, after Colorado, to enact a dedicated law governing employers’ use of artificial intelligence [1][2]. The bill, Public Act 103-0804, amends the Illinois Human Rights Act, and its operative provisions took effect January 1, 2026 [1]. It reaches any employer with one or more employees in Illinois — or hiring in Illinois — with no small-employer exemption, and law firm analyses read the notice duty as extending to applicants as well as current employees [3].
The Act creates three distinct civil rights violations. An employer may not use AI in a manner that has the effect of subjecting employees to discrimination on the basis of a protected class — even if the discrimination is unintentional. An employer may not use ZIP codes as a proxy for protected classes in AI-driven processes. And an employer may not fail to notify an employee when AI is being used in a covered employment decision [1]. The covered decisions sweep the full employment lifecycle: recruitment, hiring, promotion, renewal of employment, selection for training or apprenticeship, discharge, discipline, tenure, and the terms, privileges, or conditions of employment [1].
The definition of artificial intelligence is deliberately broad: “a machine-based system that, for explicit or implicit objectives, infers, from the input it receives, how to generate outputs such as predictions, content, recommendations, or decisions that can influence physical or virtual environments” — a definition that expressly includes generative AI [1][2]. Unlike other state laws governing AI in employment, Illinois imposed no requirement that AI be a substantial factor or the sole basis for a decision: if AI plays any role, notice is likely required [3].
One more feature matters for everything that followed. The statute directs the Illinois Department of Human Rights (IDHR) to adopt rules specifying “the circumstances and conditions that require notice, the time period for providing notice, and the means for providing notice” [1]. In other words, the legislature bound employers to a notice duty and delegated the details to an agency that had not yet written them.
Eighteen Days in the Register
On May 15, 2026, IDHR published its proposed implementing rules in the Illinois Register, amending the Department’s procedures at 56 Ill. Adm. Code 2520 [4]. The proposal added a new Subpart J — “Use of Artificial Intelligence in Employment” — with two new sections: 2520.900 (Definitions) and 2520.910 (Notice), alongside an amendment to the Department’s recordkeeping section [4]. Publication triggered a 45-day public comment period, with written comments due June 29, and a public hearing scheduled for June 10, both in person in Chicago and via WebEx [4].
Eighteen days after publication, the process stopped. On June 2, 2026, IDHR announced it was temporarily withdrawing and postponing the proposed rules, and the June 10 public hearing was “temporarily postponed” as well [5]. The agency’s full stated reason, as quoted by Ogletree Deakins: “IDHR is currently reviewing matters related to the proposed rulemaking and will provide updated information regarding next steps as it becomes available. Postponement is necessary to allow for continued collaboration with other state agencies.” [5] No revised timeline was provided.
Four months later, the silence holds. No refiled version of the rules has appeared in the Illinois Register since the withdrawal, and tracking services that follow the rulemaking report the same absence [6]. As of this article’s publication, the announcement page IDHR pointed stakeholders to returns a “Page Not Found” error. The rules that were supposed to define the notice duty exist only as a withdrawn draft — but the duty itself has been enforceable since January 1.
What the Withdrawn Rules Would Have Required
Because the draft text was published in the Register, employers can still read exactly what IDHR had in mind — and law firms have treated the withdrawn rules as the best available preview of what refiled rules will demand [7]. The operative command in proposed Section 2520.910 was blunt:
“An employer must not use artificial intelligence in any covered employment decision unless the employer provides notice of such use of artificial intelligence to its employees, including prospective employees, and their exclusive bargaining representatives.” [4]
The Trigger: Influence, Not Decision-Making
Several features of the draft explain why employers are not waiting for the refiling to begin work:
- “Use” reaches the periphery, not just the decision. The draft defined use as “any instance in which the output of an artificial intelligence system influences or facilitates a covered employment decision” — language that captures AI playing even a peripheral role, including where the output is incidental or supplementary to human decision-making [4][7]. Seyfarth Shaw’s read is that unless the rules are revised, Illinois could cover more use cases than any other state AI employment law currently on the books [7]. The core logic is a pipeline test rather than a decision test: anything that touches how a covered decision gets made counts, whether or not the machine has the final say.
- Vendors and staffing firms are on the hook too. An “agent” — any third party acting on an employer’s behalf to exercise control over recruitment, hiring, promotion, discipline, or the like — is itself an “employer” under the draft [4]. Depending on the control exercised, staffing firms, technology vendors, external recruiters, and other service providers could share compliance obligations with the employing entity [7]. The principle: whoever effectively controls the employment action cannot escape the notice duty by contracting it out.
- Notice would be continuous and multi-channel. Current employees would receive notice annually and within 30 days of adopting a new or substantially updated AI system; prospective employees would receive it as part of the job notice or posting itself [4]. Notice would have to run through all applicable channels at once: employee handbook, physical posting in a conspicuous location, intranet or external website (with a conspicuous homepage link), and job postings [4].
- Six required content elements. The draft notice would name the AI system’s developer, product name, and vendor; identify which covered employment decision the system influences; explain the system’s purpose and the categories of personal information or employee data it collects; list the types of job positions affected; provide a point of contact for questions; and state the right to request a reasonable accommodation [4]. Accessibility requirements follow: plain language, availability in the languages commonly spoken by the employer’s workforce, and reasonable accessibility for employees with disabilities [4].
- The carve-outs are narrow. Notice would not be required for AI used for ordinary business operations — designing a job posting, generating promotional text — or for software that does not meet the statutory AI definition, or for AI features in a mixed system that are not used for covered decisions [4]. Everything else with an inference function in the employment pipeline stays in scope.
Why the Withdrawal Changes Nothing, Legally
The single most important point, repeated across every legal analysis of the withdrawal: postponing the rulemaking did not postpone the law. The three violations — discriminatory effect, ZIP-code proxy, failure to notify — are created by the statute, not the rules, and they have been in effect since January 1, 2026 [5][7]. Seyfarth’s summary of the posture is that “the contours of compliant notice in Illinois remain unclear” even as the obligations bind [7]. One research tracker’s headline calls the situation what it has become: “an AI notice duty with no rules behind it” [6].
Why would an agency withdraw its own rules eighteen days into the comment period? IDHR said only that postponement was necessary for “continued collaboration with other state agencies,” and Ogletree Deakins notes the agency may be considering substantive changes before taking public input [5]. The practical effect is the same either way: enforcement risk now attaches to notice failures even though no regulator has defined what a compliant notice must contain, when it must be delivered, or through which channels. The statute ordered IDHR to answer exactly those three questions; the answers are missing.
The Recordkeeping Preview
The withdrawal also complicates the recordkeeping picture. The same proposal would have amended the Department’s records-preservation section, and the Register’s own small-business analysis concedes that “Procedures for tracking issuance of notices will be required” [4]. Employers who wait for final rules to build those procedures will have to reconstruct their notice history after the fact.
The Federal Backdrop Does Not Pause the State Clock
Employers hoping for relief from Washington have reason to wait indefinitely rather than act. On December 11, 2025, President Trump signed an executive order directing the Department of Justice to challenge state laws that regulate AI, including laws like HB 3773 [3]. But as Reinhart Boerner Van Deuren noted when the order issued, an act of Congress is typically necessary to preempt state laws, and the executive order’s own legal future is uncertain [3]. The core logic for employers is that preemption is a bet on a timeline no one controls, while the notice duty is a compliance task whose deadline already passed on January 1, 2026.
What Employers Should Do Now
Legal analyses converge on a short list of steps that make sense even without final rules:
- Audit the AI footprint first. Employers should inventory the tools used across the employment lifecycle — recruiting, screening, monitoring, discipline — including AI embedded in ordinary HR software that may trigger notice obligations without anyone deciding to “adopt AI” [3]. The breadth of the statutory definition makes the inventory the hard part; every downstream judgment depends on knowing where inference systems touch covered decisions.
- Draft notice against the six-element preview. Seyfarth recommends using the withdrawal window to expand notice and recordkeeping processes so that when the rulemaking resumes, employers “are not starting from scratch” [7]. A notice that names the system, the decision, the data, the positions, a contact, and accommodation rights satisfies the withdrawn draft — and cannot be less than what the statute requires.
- Update nondiscrimination policies, especially on ZIP codes. The proxy prohibition operates independently of the notice duty, and ZIP-code inputs are common in ad targeting and screening tools; Reinhart flags policy review on exactly this point [3].
- Build the notice log before the rules demand it. The Register’s small-business analysis already anticipates tracking issuance of notices as a compliance procedure [4]. A dated record of who was noticed, when, and through which channel is cheap insurance under a law that treats violations as civil rights violations.
- Watch the Register, not just the press releases. IDHR pointed stakeholders to its legislative updates page, but the binding event will be the republication of proposed rules in the weekly Illinois Register, where the last version appeared on May 15 [4][5].
The Vacuum Is the Policy Story
Illinois chose a disclosure-based model for AI in employment: the law’s enforcement theory is that workers cannot contest decisions they cannot see. That choice makes the notice regime the load-bearing wall of the whole statute — and for nearly a year that wall has been held up by the statute alone, with the agency’s blueprint published, withdrawn, and unpublished again. A rule withdrawal is not deregulation; it is a delay of clarity, not of duty. The interpretive risk does not disappear while IDHR collaborates with other agencies. It shifts onto every employer making a good-faith guess at what “notice” means.
For other states watching the second mover in this space, the lesson cuts both ways. Statutory text can bind before agencies speak, which argues for drafting laws that are self-executing in their essentials. But Illinois also shows the cost of delegating the details: eighteen days of proposed rules, a canceled hearing, a 404 where the announcement used to be, and thousands of employers writing notices to a standard that does not officially exist.
References
[1] Illinois General Assembly — [PRIMARY] Public Act 103-0804 (House Bill 3773), amending the Illinois Human Rights Act, 775 ILCS 5. Signed August 9, 2024; effective January 1, 2026.
[2] DLA Piper — [SECONDARY] Mobley, Todd, and Eigen, Zev. “Illinois becomes second state to enact AI law for employers.” August 29, 2024.
[3] Reinhart Boerner Van Deuren — [SECONDARY] Gentry, Michael J., and DeLange, Matt. “Illinois Employers Face AI Transparency Deadline Despite New Executive Order.” December 18, 2025.
[4] Illinois Register — [PRIMARY] Volume 50, Issue 20. “Department of Human Rights: Notice of Proposed Amendments,” 56 Ill. Adm. Code 2520 (Subpart J — Use of Artificial Intelligence in Employment). May 15, 2026.
[5] Ogletree Deakins — [SECONDARY] Colvin, Jennifer L., Francis, Simone R.D., Ochs, Danielle, and Zagger, Zachary V. “Illinois Postpones Proposed Regulations on AI in Employment.” June 4, 2026.
[6] CASRAI — [SECONDARY] “Illinois HB 3773: An AI Notice Duty With No Rules Behind It.” Updated September 25, 2026.
[7] Seyfarth Shaw — [SECONDARY] “Illinois Department of Human Rights Temporarily Withdraws Proposed Rules on Use of Artificial Intelligence in Employment.” June 8, 2026.
AI automated and generated content. Human reviewed.