California Cracks Down on AI Deepfakes in Elections with Trio of Laws

California Cracks Down on AI Deepfakes in Elections with Trio of Laws

Three bills signed by Governor Gavin Newsom in September 2024 target AI-generated deepfakes in political advertising, election communications, and campaign materials — the most aggressive state-level response to election-related synthetic media.

AB 2655 — Defending Democracy from Deepfakes Act

The most expansive of the three, AB 2655 prohibits the distribution of materially deceptive audio or visual media of elected officials, candidates, and election officials within 120 days before an election. “Materially deceptive” means a reasonable person would believe it’s authentic and it could harm the subject’s reputation or electoral prospects.

The law also requires large online platforms (defined as those with at least 1 million California monthly users) to:

  • Remove or label reported deepfakes within specified timeframes
  • Provide a reporting mechanism for flagged content
  • Maintain publicly accessible lists of removed deepfake material

AB 730 — Election Deepfakes (Communications)

AB 730 makes it unlawful to distribute within 60 days before an election any deceptive audio or visual media of a candidate that is intended to injure their reputation or deceive voters. The law includes exemptions for parody, satire, and content that includes a prominent disclosure label.

AB 2839 — Manipulated Media in Campaign Communications

AB 2839 prohibits the distribution of campaign communications containing materially deceptive images, audio, or video of a candidate that knowingly deceives voters — expanded from a prior law that only covered audio. Notably, this law applies year-round, not just before elections.

First Amendment Challenges

Several of these laws face constitutional challenges. In Bloomberg et al. v. Bowen and related cases, plaintiffs argue the laws violate the First Amendment’s protections for political speech, parody, and satire. A federal judge granted a preliminary injunction blocking enforcement of AB 2839 in October 2024 against a plaintiff who posted a manipulated video of Vice President Harris, finding the law likely violated the First Amendment.

Context

These California laws are part of a broader wave of state-level deepfake legislation. Texas SB 751, passed in 2023, similarly criminalizes the creation and distribution of deepfake videos intended to influence elections. The EU AI Act also addresses deepfakes, requiring providers of AI systems that generate synthetic media to disclose that content is AI-generated.

Primary Sources


AI automated and generated content. Human reviewed. All policy text is summarized from the primary sources linked above.

The Weekly AI Policy Brief

AI policy moves fast. Get the week’s developments, new trackers, and podcast episodes in one short email — free, ad-free, no spam.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *